What Went Wrong?

So, nothing happened in the legislature this year for new cities in central DeKalb.  There won’t be a vote for any cities. We can all be Cubs fans and say “Wait until next year”.  For some folks, that’s a favorable outcome. Like any political question it’s not a universal one-sided issue. But some of us would have liked to have had a city government that would be more responsive and effective than the DeKalb County government.

Maybe it would be good to think of what happened, and try to avoid making the same mistakes in the future.


First off, we all have to recognize that there’s no consensus in any of this. And clearly there’s a lot of misunderstanding about what government should do, and how it should work.

I made several posts about pot holes in different areas of central DeKalb. Several comments showed that people thought pot holes were normal, and eventually they would be taken care of. The same people might have sued Coca Cola if a can was dented badly. (But they’re a business, and are expected to do it right.) Unfortunately, people have very low expectations of their government. And a lot of people think there’s no way to do better.

None of us did a really good job of explaining that it’s possible to do a good job of government. It is possible to be effective.  It’s possible to get things done. None of us did an effective job of convincing people that change was in their interest.


And then there’s borders! I’m not the only one who has said that there’s nothing magical about borders. They’re just a decision that people make. We can look all day for history, logic, appearance or “relationship”; unfortunately none of them are the point. The point is “What works for all parties”. What accomplishes the important goals of city creation? Is everyone included? Does it make sense? As soon as someone says “it has to be this way”, you know there’s a problem.


But one thing that is clear about borders is that no one understands why there should be a series of changes rearranging them. Those aren’t plots on a map – they’re people. You can’t say this neighborhood should be in your city one day and out the next -- or out one day, and in the next -- without having a broad feeling that this process makes no sense.

We all knew that there were competing views of the “best” way of designing cities. We knew it six months ago. There was ample time to discuss and come to an agreement in 2013. For various reasons members of different groups felt that they were better off to wait until they thought the time was right for them. Some people felt it was better to make a deal with one group rather than another. Some felt like they should talk to one group but not another. As a result all of us went into a legislature that had said in advance that they were not going to draw lines; they wanted an agreement among the groups. The one thing for sure is that next time there needs to be a consensus going in.


And we have a problem with an attitude among our government officials.  They used a hypothetical “Let’s fix the county” as an argument against cities. But their idea of fixing things is getting more money – changing tax rules. They have argued against any real change in the way the county is run. They have spent our money in non-productive ways. They like things the way they are.

And let’s get serious about the question.  The reason for creating a city is to have local control over local issues. None of the many “proposals” for fixing DeKalb County address those issues.  They’re a completely different realm of problem. We would all like to fix the governance problem with DeKalb; we’re all citizens of the County. And if anything actually happens, we’ll still need sidewalks here.


I’ll try to discuss some of the issues and players in the future posts.

This post is contributed by a community member. The views expressed in this blog are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Patch Media Corporation. Everyone is welcome to submit a post to Patch. If you'd like to post a blog, go here to get started.

Brett April 25, 2014 at 05:40 PM
Truth - you got all that from "I've also attended some Lakeside meetings, and know that they thought only God (possibly) was worthy of discussion with them." I mean I understand you wanted to speak your views, but it's a stretch to say they have anything to do with Mikeatl's or mine.
Worker Bee April 25, 2014 at 05:55 PM
C'mon Brett. A lot of us went to Lakeside meetings. Most people came out with the same impression as Mike's. Those people thought no one's opinion was worth anything except their own (except possibly God).
Worker Bee April 25, 2014 at 05:59 PM
And Jim, I think you're on the track. Someone once pointed out that Lakeside was a loose circle drawn around their houses, with various attempts to grab commercial space to give them some money to play with. And the "vision thing" was not real good here.
newsydon April 27, 2014 at 09:41 AM
anybody who believed anything they heard at a lakeside meeting needs to reevaluate their life. think first: are these people politicians? then realize the answer -- i'm saying what sounds good to you. the reality has no relevance.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »